Gold $4,467.31
-33.16
Silver $79.42
-2.58
Platinum $2,344.89
-118.46
Palladium $1,816.63
-49.32
Rhodium $9,900.00
Gold $4,467.31
-33.16
Silver $79.42
-2.58
Gold $4,467.31
-33.16
Silver $79.42
-2.58
Platinum $2,344.89
-118.46
Metal
Change
Bid
Ask
Gold
-33.16
$4,457.99
$4,467.31
Silver
-2.58
$77.77
$79.42
Platinum
-118.46
$2,318.85
$2,344.89
Palladium
-49.32
$1,764.11
$1,816.63
Rhodium
$9,500.00
$9,900.00
New
2025
Gold
Silver
Other
US Coins
Foreign Coins
Sale
+800-735-1311
Close
Search
Sort By
Default
Name
Date (oldest)
Date (newest)
Price (lowest)
Price (highest)
home
Nickels
Buffalo Nickels
Certified Buffalo Nickels
Back to:
Buffalo Nickels
List
Grid
Default
Certified Buffalo Nickels
OUT OF STOCK
PRODUCT ID: 55749
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1913 S Type 2 AU53 NGC
As low as
$649.00
(0 avail.)
Out of stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$649.00
$655.49
$674.96
Notify Me!
PRODUCT ID: 58409
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1913 Type 1 MS66 NGC
As low as
$395.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$395.00
$398.95
$410.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 6326
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1913-D Type 1 MS65 NGC
As low as
$325.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$325.00
$328.25
$338.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 56817
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1913-S T2 G4 PCGS
As low as
$225.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$225.00
$227.25
$234.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 57738
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1914 MS64 ANACS
As low as
$295.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$295.00
$297.95
$306.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58410
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1915-D MS62 PCGS
As low as
$350.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$350.00
$353.50
$364.00
Add To Cart
OUT OF STOCK
PRODUCT ID: 56703
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1916 MS65 PCGS
As low as
$439.00
(0 avail.)
Out of stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$439.00
$443.39
$456.56
Notify Me!
PRODUCT ID: 56819
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1917-D VF30 PCGS
As low as
$130.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$130.00
$131.30
$135.20
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 13879
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1918 Over 7-D Fine Details (Scratches) NGC
As low as
$1,595.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$1,595.00
$1,610.95
$1,658.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 50998
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1918-S AU58 NGC
As low as
$1,075.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$1,075.00
$1,085.75
$1,118.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 41369
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1918/7-D F details PCGS
As low as
$1,595.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$1,595.00
$1,610.95
$1,658.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 42082
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1918/7-D VF details NGC
As low as
$2,950.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$2,950.00
$2,979.50
$3,068.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 50652
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1920-S EF40 ANACS
As low as
$250.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$250.00
$252.50
$260.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 54023
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1921-S F12 ANACS
As low as
$159.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$159.00
$160.59
$165.36
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 41372
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1921-S XF Details PCGS
As low as
$595.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$595.00
$600.95
$618.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 55894
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1925 MS64 PCGS
As low as
$295.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$295.00
$297.95
$306.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 57357
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1925-S VF35 PCGS
As low as
$175.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$175.00
$176.75
$182.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 6373
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1926 MS65 PCGS
As low as
$295.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$295.00
$297.95
$306.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58413
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1926-S VF25 NGC
As low as
$249.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$249.00
$251.49
$258.96
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 56173
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1926-S VF35 PCGS
As low as
$495.00
(2 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$495.00
$499.95
$514.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58417
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1931-S MS64 PCGS
As low as
$209.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$209.00
$211.09
$217.36
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58418
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1931-S MS65 NGC
As low as
$365.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$365.00
$368.65
$379.60
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 8314
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1934 MS65 NGC
As low as
$225.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$225.00
$227.25
$234.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58430
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1935 MS65 NGC
As low as
$195.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$195.00
$196.95
$202.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58429
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1935 MS65 PCGS
As low as
$195.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$195.00
$196.95
$202.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58431
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1935-S MS65 PCGS
As low as
$239.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$239.00
$241.39
$248.56
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58419
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1936 MS65 PCGS rattler
As low as
$149.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$149.00
$150.49
$154.96
Add To Cart
OUT OF STOCK
PRODUCT ID: 15490
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-D 3 Legs AU58 NGC
As low as
$2,795.00
(0 avail.)
Out of stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$2,795.00
$2,822.95
$2,906.80
Notify Me!
PRODUCT ID: 58424
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-D 3 Legs AU58 PCGS
As low as
$3,250.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$3,250.00
$3,282.50
$3,380.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58423
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-D 3 Legs EF40 ICG
As low as
$995.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$995.00
$1,004.95
$1,034.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58422
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-D 3 Legs XF40 PCGS
As low as
$1,125.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$1,125.00
$1,136.25
$1,170.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 20663
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-D MS66 NGC
As low as
$149.50
(16 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$149.50
$151.00
$155.48
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 20653
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-D MS67 NGC
As low as
$595.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$595.00
$600.95
$618.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 55224
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-S MS65 PCGS
As low as
$120.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$120.00
$121.20
$124.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 24504
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-S MS66 PCGS
As low as
$95.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$95.00
$95.95
$98.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 8135
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1938 D over S MS65 PCGS
As low as
$195.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$195.00
$196.95
$202.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58426
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1938-D over D MS66 PCGS
As low as
$159.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$159.00
$160.59
$165.36
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 51145
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1938-D/S MS65 NGC
As low as
$195.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$195.00
$196.95
$202.80
Add To Cart
OUT OF STOCK
PRODUCT ID: 55749
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1913 S Type 2 AU53 NGC
As low as
$649.00
(0 avail.)
Out of stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$649.00
$655.49
$674.96
Notify Me!
PRODUCT ID: 58409
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1913 Type 1 MS66 NGC
As low as
$395.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$395.00
$398.95
$410.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 6326
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1913-D Type 1 MS65 NGC
As low as
$325.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$325.00
$328.25
$338.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 56817
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1913-S T2 G4 PCGS
As low as
$225.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$225.00
$227.25
$234.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 57738
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1914 MS64 ANACS
As low as
$295.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$295.00
$297.95
$306.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58410
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1915-D MS62 PCGS
As low as
$350.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$350.00
$353.50
$364.00
Add To Cart
OUT OF STOCK
PRODUCT ID: 56703
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1916 MS65 PCGS
As low as
$439.00
(0 avail.)
Out of stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$439.00
$443.39
$456.56
Notify Me!
PRODUCT ID: 56819
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1917-D VF30 PCGS
As low as
$130.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$130.00
$131.30
$135.20
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 13879
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1918 Over 7-D Fine Details (Scratches) NGC
As low as
$1,595.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$1,595.00
$1,610.95
$1,658.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 50998
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1918-S AU58 NGC
As low as
$1,075.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$1,075.00
$1,085.75
$1,118.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 41369
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1918/7-D F details PCGS
As low as
$1,595.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$1,595.00
$1,610.95
$1,658.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 42082
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1918/7-D VF details NGC
As low as
$2,950.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$2,950.00
$2,979.50
$3,068.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 50652
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1920-S EF40 ANACS
As low as
$250.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$250.00
$252.50
$260.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 54023
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1921-S F12 ANACS
As low as
$159.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$159.00
$160.59
$165.36
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 41372
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1921-S XF Details PCGS
As low as
$595.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$595.00
$600.95
$618.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 55894
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1925 MS64 PCGS
As low as
$295.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$295.00
$297.95
$306.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 57357
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1925-S VF35 PCGS
As low as
$175.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$175.00
$176.75
$182.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 6373
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1926 MS65 PCGS
As low as
$295.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$295.00
$297.95
$306.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58413
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1926-S VF25 NGC
As low as
$249.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$249.00
$251.49
$258.96
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 56173
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1926-S VF35 PCGS
As low as
$495.00
(2 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$495.00
$499.95
$514.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58417
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1931-S MS64 PCGS
As low as
$209.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$209.00
$211.09
$217.36
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58418
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1931-S MS65 NGC
As low as
$365.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$365.00
$368.65
$379.60
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 8314
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1934 MS65 NGC
As low as
$225.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$225.00
$227.25
$234.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58430
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1935 MS65 NGC
As low as
$195.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$195.00
$196.95
$202.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58429
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1935 MS65 PCGS
As low as
$195.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$195.00
$196.95
$202.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58431
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1935-S MS65 PCGS
As low as
$239.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$239.00
$241.39
$248.56
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58419
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1936 MS65 PCGS rattler
As low as
$149.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$149.00
$150.49
$154.96
Add To Cart
OUT OF STOCK
PRODUCT ID: 15490
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-D 3 Legs AU58 NGC
As low as
$2,795.00
(0 avail.)
Out of stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$2,795.00
$2,822.95
$2,906.80
Notify Me!
PRODUCT ID: 58424
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-D 3 Legs AU58 PCGS
As low as
$3,250.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$3,250.00
$3,282.50
$3,380.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58423
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-D 3 Legs EF40 ICG
As low as
$995.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$995.00
$1,004.95
$1,034.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58422
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-D 3 Legs XF40 PCGS
As low as
$1,125.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$1,125.00
$1,136.25
$1,170.00
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 20663
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-D MS66 NGC
As low as
$149.50
(16 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$149.50
$151.00
$155.48
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 20653
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-D MS67 NGC
As low as
$595.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$595.00
$600.95
$618.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 55224
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-S MS65 PCGS
As low as
$120.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$120.00
$121.20
$124.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 24504
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1937-S MS66 PCGS
As low as
$95.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$95.00
$95.95
$98.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 8135
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1938 D over S MS65 PCGS
As low as
$195.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$195.00
$196.95
$202.80
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 58426
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1938-D over D MS66 PCGS
As low as
$159.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$159.00
$160.59
$165.36
Add To Cart
PRODUCT ID: 51145
Certified Buffalo Nickel 1938-D/S MS65 NGC
As low as
$195.00
(1 avail.)
In stock
Simple Pricing
Qty
Wire/Check
Bitcoin
CC/Paypal
Any
$195.00
$196.95
$202.80
Add To Cart
Market summary
Meta/Chg
Bid
Ask
Gold
-33.16
$4,457.99
$4,467.31
Silver
-2.58
$77.77
$79.42
Platinum
-118.46
$2,318.85
$2,344.89
Palladium
-49.32
$1,764.11
$1,816.63
Rhodium
$9,500.00
$9,900.00
Certified Buffalo Nickels
Read more
You may also like
1928 $100 Federal Reserve Note VF
$195.00
Certified Commemorative Half Dollar Missouri MS63 PCGS
$695.00
Kennedy Half Dollar 1971-S Proof
$3.95
View All
