-
Inventory:
OUT OF STOCK
- Product ID: 11527
Checkout
The 1911-D Indian Head $2.5 Gold Quarter Eagle is one of the most coveted and historically significant issues in the entire Indian Head Quarter Eagle series. This coin, struck at the Denver Mint, holds the distinction of being the only quarter eagle in the series ever produced at that mint and is famously recognized as the rarest and most desirable date in the set. Designed by Bela Lyon Pratt and introduced in 1908, the Indian Head Quarter Eagle series broke radically from tradition by using an incuse design—one in which the devices and inscriptions are recessed below the coin’s surface. The 1911-D issue is not only unique for its mintmark but also for its extremely low mintage, which has earned it a reputation as the “key date” of the series. Even in Extra Fine condition, the 1911-D is a prized numismatic treasure that commands significant premiums and admiration among collectors.
The obverse of the coin features the left-facing profile of a Native American chief wearing a feathered headdress, with the word “LIBERTY” inscribed above and thirteen stars encircling the design. The date “1911” is placed just below the portrait. This recessed design gives the coin a sculpted, carved appearance, unlike any other U.S. circulating coin. On the reverse, a stately bald eagle stands perched on a bundle of arrows entwined with an olive branch. Around the eagle are the inscriptions “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,” “E PLURIBUS UNUM,” “IN GOD WE TRUST,” and the denomination “2½ DOLLARS.” The distinguishing mark of this issue, the “D” mintmark of the Denver Mint, appears to the left of the eagle's tail feathers. Because of the coin’s incuse design, the mintmark can be faint or lightly struck, and sharply defined mintmarks are particularly desirable among specialists.
The 1911-D issue was struck at the Denver Mint with a mintage of only 55,680 pieces, the lowest in the entire Indian Quarter Eagle series. This mintage, coupled with relatively poor distribution and extensive circulation, has resulted in very low survival rates, especially in higher grades. Many of the coins that entered circulation quickly picked up wear, making Extra Fine examples such as this one considerably scarce and desirable. The limited production of this coin at Denver adds another layer of historical significance, as it marked the first and only time the Quarter Eagle was minted at that facility. The Denver Mint, established in 1906, had only recently begun striking gold coinage, and the 1911-D quarter eagle stands as its lone contribution to this denomination in the Indian Head series.
In Extra Fine (XF) condition, a 1911-D $2.5 Indian Gold Coin shows moderate but even wear on the highest points of the design while retaining all major features with strong clarity. On the obverse, the details in the Native American’s headdress, hair, and facial profile are slightly softened from use but still visible. The stars and date remain sharp. On the reverse, the eagle’s breast, wings, and legs exhibit some smoothing, yet the outline of feathers and overall composition remain clear and easily identifiable. Importantly, the “D” mintmark is typically visible, though not always sharply struck. XF examples retain some residual luster in protected areas and tend to show honest wear rather than damage, making them highly collectible despite not being in Mint State condition.
The coin is composed of 90% gold and 10% copper, weighs 4.18 grams, and contains 0.12094 troy ounces of pure gold. Its small size—just 18 millimeters in diameter—belies its immense numismatic stature. The copper alloy gives it durability and a rich reddish-gold hue that collectors find especially attractive. The incuse design, while revolutionary and initially controversial, actually helped protect the coin’s features from excessive wear, as the recessed devices were less exposed to friction. Nonetheless, due to the softness of gold, even modest handling over the years has left most surviving 1911-D examples with wear, placing well-preserved circulated coins like this XF specimen in strong demand.
The 1911-D occupies a place of prestige in the Indian Head Quarter Eagle series and is considered essential for collectors seeking a complete date and mintmark set. Its low mintage, one-year-only mint origin, and the general difficulty of finding examples with strong strikes and full mintmarks contribute to its reputation as the series’ “key.” Demand for the 1911-D has remained robust for decades, and even heavily circulated specimens command prices far above those of common dates. Extra Fine examples offer an especially attractive balance between price and preservation—possessing sharp detail and historical integrity at a cost substantially below uncirculated examples, which are rare and expensive, particularly in grades above MS62.
The market for the 1911-D $2.5 gold coin remains strong across all grades, but XF coins are particularly sought after by intermediate to advanced collectors who prioritize completeness, authenticity, and character. Since many 1911-D coins entered circulation, relatively few escaped extensive wear, and fewer still retained a sharply struck mintmark. XF coins that combine solid detail with a well-defined “D” mintmark are prized and often sold at a premium. Authentication and third-party certification are recommended for all 1911-D specimens due to the prevalence of counterfeits and altered mintmarks. Certified examples from reputable grading services provide assurance of authenticity and facilitate safe buying and selling in the numismatic marketplace.
Historically, the 1911-D quarter eagle reflects broader trends in early 20th-century American coinage, when the U.S. Mint was experimenting with new design approaches and engaging with modern artistic movements. Bela Lyon Pratt’s design, part of President Theodore Roosevelt’s campaign to modernize American coinage, has endured as a landmark in U.S. numismatic art. The fact that this bold design was paired with a one-year, low-mintage production from the Denver Mint only enhances its legacy. The 1911-D thus serves as both a numismatic rarity and a symbol of an era of transformation and innovation in American currency.
In conclusion, the 1911-D $2.5 Indian Head Gold Coin in Extra Fine condition is a legendary issue in American numismatics, combining extreme rarity, historical significance, and unique design. As the only Indian Quarter Eagle struck at the Denver Mint and the lowest mintage coin in the series, it holds a central place in any collection of U.S. gold coinage. In XF grade, it offers strong detail, visible mintmark, and the charm of light honest circulation wear—making it a highly desirable piece for collectors and historians alike. Whether pursued as a key-date investment, a series completion piece, or a standalone rarity, the 1911-D Quarter Eagle continues to captivate the numismatic world with its enduring allure.