-
Inventory:
OUT OF STOCK
- Product ID: 57112
Checkout
The Certified 1951-S Roosevelt Dime graded MS65 by PCGS in an old “Rattler” holder represents a high-quality, early-date example from the Roosevelt dime series, preserved in one of the most iconic slab styles in numismatic history. The "Rattler" refers to the original generation of PCGS holders issued between 1986 and 1989, so named for the slight movement of the coin inside its clear plastic shell. These early holders have gained collector prestige for their nostalgic value and perceived potential for undergraded coins. With a Mint State 65 (MS65) designation, this 1951-S Roosevelt Dime exemplifies a brilliant, sharply struck, and well-preserved coin from the post–World War II era, offering eye appeal and collectibility for both series specialists and slab enthusiasts.
The Roosevelt dime replaced the beloved Mercury dime in 1946 following the death of President Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1945. Roosevelt had played a significant role in the fight against polio and was widely admired by the public, prompting the U.S. Mint to honor him on the nation’s ten-cent coin. The design was created by John R. Sinnock, Chief Engraver of the U.S. Mint, and it was first issued in 1946. The obverse of the Roosevelt dime features a left-facing portrait of President Roosevelt, accompanied by the inscriptions “LIBERTY,” “IN GOD WE TRUST,” and the date. The reverse features a torch in the center, flanked by an olive branch and oak branch to represent liberty, peace, and strength, respectively, along with the motto “E PLURIBUS UNUM.”
The 1951-S Roosevelt Dime was struck at the San Francisco Mint, with a total mintage of 31,630,000 coins. It bears the “S” mintmark on the reverse to the left of the torch’s base. Although this mintage is relatively moderate compared to Philadelphia issues, many 1951-S dimes entered circulation, and well-struck Mint State examples are sought by collectors. The 1951-S is especially popular among those building complete date and mintmark sets of Roosevelt dimes, as well as those focused on the first decade of the series. While not a key date, it is respected for its clean design and solid availability in Mint State grades.
PCGS’s MS65 grade certifies the coin as a Gem Uncirculated specimen, featuring above-average luster, sharp detail, and only light contact marks that do not distract from its overall appearance. For the 1951-S, this grade typically means a crisp strike on Roosevelt’s hair, facial features, and the reverse elements, including the torch flame and the adjacent branches. While some San Francisco Mint issues can exhibit slightly weaker strikes in the series, well-struck 1951-S dimes like this one are known for full design clarity and strong luster. A true MS65 example will have appealing brilliance, with minimal bag marks and no signs of wear.
One of the standout aspects of this coin is its encapsulation in a PCGS “Rattler” holder. These early holders were the first generation of PCGS slabs and are widely collected today for their historical significance. The coins inside these holders often have conservative grades by modern standards, leading collectors and dealers to view them as upgrade candidates. However, many choose to preserve Rattler coins as-is, preferring the nostalgic value of the original holder and label. The green and white label includes the coin’s date, mintmark, grade, and a unique certification number, all printed in a typeface recognizable from PCGS’s early years.
While this 1951-S Roosevelt Dime is not designated as Full Bands (FB), the MS65 grade suggests strong detail overall, and many non-FB examples still show well-defined horizontal bands on the torch. Full Bands designation—indicating complete separation in the torch’s horizontal lines—commands a premium but is not a necessity for many collectors, especially when the coin boasts vibrant mint luster and crisp design elements. In this grade, the coin often exhibits frosty or satiny surfaces, and some may show light toning from long-term storage, particularly when housed in early holders like the Rattler, which are less airtight than modern slabs.
The Roosevelt dime’s composition in 1951 was 90% silver and 10% copper, a standard that continued until 1964 when silver was removed from circulating coinage. This makes all pre-1965 Roosevelt dimes desirable for both numismatic and bullion purposes. However, coins like this certified MS65 example stand well above their melt value due to their condition and collector recognition. Silver weight for this coin is 0.07234 troy ounces, but its true value lies in its preservation, grading, and holder pedigree.
Collectors of the Roosevelt dime series often seek out coins in original PCGS Rattler holders as part of a “holder type set” or as an intersection of early third-party grading history and numismatic preservation. The 1951-S MS65 Rattler offers both vintage charm and tangible numismatic history, capturing a moment when third-party grading was in its infancy and standards were still evolving. For this reason, these early slabs often bring strong premiums at auction, especially when combined with attractive eye appeal and high-grade certification.
The 1951-S Roosevelt Dime in MS65 is an ideal coin for collectors building a mid-20th-century silver type set, a complete Roosevelt dime registry set, or a PCGS Rattler slab collection. It offers a glimpse into early postwar numismatics, when the U.S. Mint was operating in peacetime and returning to normal production routines. Moreover, it reflects the beginnings of the third-party grading movement that has since revolutionized the hobby. Whether appreciated for its luster, strike, design, or historical encapsulation, this certified piece makes a distinguished addition to any cabinet of classic American coinage.
In conclusion, the Certified 1951-S Roosevelt Dime MS65 in a PCGS Rattler holder stands as a charming and high-grade representative of early Roosevelt coinage, elevated by the significance of its vintage encapsulation. With its brilliant surfaces, precise details, and iconic presidential portrait, the coin is both an artistic and historical artifact. Its place in the Rattler series makes it especially appealing for collectors who value early PCGS history and the evolution of coin grading. In this form, the 1951-S Roosevelt dime is more than a silver coin—it is a time capsule from the dawn of modern numismatics.