-
Inventory:
1 In Stock
- Product ID: 45833
Checkout
The 1916-S $5 Gold Indian Half Eagle in Extra Fine (XF) condition is a significant and desirable coin from one of the most iconic and innovative U.S. gold series. Designed by Bela Lyon Pratt, the Indian Head Half Eagle series was introduced in 1908 and continued through 1929. What sets this series apart is its unique incuse design, in which the devices and inscriptions are sunken into the coin’s surface rather than raised above it. The 1916-S issue, struck at the San Francisco Mint, represents one of the lower-mintage dates in the series and is the final issue before a 13-year hiatus. With its limited production, distinct artistic design, and historical context, the 1916-S $5 Indian holds a special place in American numismatics.
The Indian Head design, developed by sculptor Bela Lyon Pratt under the direction of President Theodore Roosevelt, marked a bold departure from previous U.S. coinage. Roosevelt sought to elevate American coins to the level of fine art, and Pratt’s innovative incuse technique achieved that vision. The obverse features a left-facing profile of a Native American chieftain in full feathered headdress, a strong and dignified image. Surrounding the portrait are thirteen stars, the word “LIBERTY” above, and the date “1916” at the bottom. The recessed surfaces give the design a sculptural, chiseled appearance that was ahead of its time and remains unique among circulating U.S. coins.
The reverse showcases a majestic eagle standing on a bundle of arrows with an olive branch intertwined, symbolizing strength in readiness for war balanced by a desire for peace. The inscriptions include “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” above, “E PLURIBUS UNUM” to the left, “IN GOD WE TRUST” to the right, and the denomination “FIVE DOLLARS” at the bottom. Like the obverse, the reverse elements are incuse, giving the coin a recessed and highly tactile design. This feature initially drew criticism from bankers who feared the design might harbor dirt or wear more quickly, but the coins proved durable in circulation.
The 1916-S $5 Indian was struck at the San Francisco Mint, as denoted by the small “S” mintmark located to the left of the arrows on the reverse. It was the last $5 Indian struck before production ceased during World War I and the post-war economic shifts of the early 1920s. Only 240,000 pieces were minted, one of the lowest totals for the entire series, contributing to its scarcity today. The series would not resume until 1929, when one final issue was released before the Great Depression and the gold recall of 1933 effectively ended gold coin circulation in the U.S.
In Extra Fine condition, the 1916-S $5 Indian exhibits moderate wear on the high points of the design, including the cheekbone and feathers of the headdress on the obverse and the eagle’s wing and breast feathers on the reverse. Despite this wear, significant detail remains visible, especially in the recessed areas, and the coin retains a pleasing, even color. XF coins generally show minimal contact marks, as the incuse design tends to protect the devices from abrasions that would otherwise mar raised reliefs on traditional coinage.
The surfaces of an XF 1916-S typically retain traces of mint luster in the protected areas, especially around the devices and near the rims. The fields may exhibit some light smoothing due to circulation, but no major detracting marks or blemishes are expected in this grade. The coin's edges and legends should be clear and readable, and the overall eye appeal is solid for collectors who prefer original surfaces and historical character over uncirculated brilliance.
The 1916-S is often considered a semi-key date in the $5 Indian series due to its low mintage and final-year status. While not as rare as the 1909-O or the 1929, it is far less common than most Philadelphia and Denver issues and commands a premium in all grades. Its relative scarcity in Extra Fine condition, combined with its historical and artistic value, makes it a sought-after piece for collectors completing the series or assembling a type set of 20th-century U.S. gold coinage.
Each $5 Indian Half Eagle is composed of 90% gold and 10% copper, with a weight of 8.359 grams and a diameter of 21.6 millimeters. The gold content amounts to 0.24187 troy ounces, making it an attractive choice for collectors seeking both numismatic and bullion value. The coin's intrinsic gold worth helps maintain a strong price floor, while its collectible premiums elevate its value above melt, especially for better dates like the 1916-S in XF and higher.
The historical context surrounding the 1916-S adds to its importance. Struck during a period of economic uncertainty and global conflict, the coin reflects the closing chapter of circulating gold coinage in the United States. The outbreak of World War I and the shift toward paper currency and centralized banking signaled a major transformation in American monetary policy. As the final pre-1929 issue, the 1916-S marks the end of an era and serves as a tangible link to the nation's past monetary practices and artistic endeavors.
The Certified $5 Gold Indian 1916-S in Extra Fine condition is a treasured numismatic artifact, showcasing innovative design, historical resonance, and enduring scarcity. With its low mintage, final-year status, and distinct appearance, it continues to captivate collectors more than a century after its release. For those drawn to American gold coinage and the artistry of early 20th-century design, this coin offers a remarkable blend of beauty, rarity, and historical weight, making it a prized addition to any collection.