-
Inventory:
OUT OF STOCK
- Product ID: 45834
Checkout
The 1909-S $5 Gold Indian Half Eagle in Very Fine (VF) condition is a scarce and highly respected issue from one of the most artistically distinctive gold coin series in American history. Part of the Indian Head Half Eagle series designed by Bela Lyon Pratt, the 1909-S was minted during a pivotal time in U.S. coinage, reflecting President Theodore Roosevelt’s initiative to elevate the aesthetic quality of circulating coins. The series, struck from 1908 to 1929, is famous for its innovative incuse design—a technique unique among U.S. coins, where the devices and legends are recessed rather than raised. The 1909-S, bearing the mark of the San Francisco Mint, is one of the more elusive entries in this series, especially in circulated grades like VF.
The Indian Head Half Eagle series broke with longstanding numismatic tradition. Rather than featuring a classical figure of Liberty, Bela Lyon Pratt's design introduced a left-facing Native American chieftain in full ceremonial headdress. This obverse image, austere and dignified, is surrounded by thirteen stars and the word “LIBERTY” at the top, with the date “1909” positioned just below the neckline. Unlike other gold coinage of the time, this design was not struck in high relief; instead, it was pressed incuse into the coin, making the overall appearance subtler but deeply expressive. The sunken nature of the design also helped protect it from wear over time, even during active circulation.
The reverse of the coin features a regal standing bald eagle, perched confidently on a bundle of arrows, with an olive branch intertwined to convey the nation’s desire for peace and preparedness for defense. Surrounding the eagle are the inscriptions “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,” “E PLURIBUS UNUM,” and “IN GOD WE TRUST,” with the denomination “FIVE DOLLARS” appearing near the bottom. To the left of the arrows, just above the rim, lies the mintmark “S,” indicating the coin’s origin at the San Francisco Mint. The incuse style gives the eagle a low-profile but sculptural look, and the composition of both sides showcases Pratt’s minimalist and powerful artistic vision.
The 1909-S issue had a modest mintage of 297,200 coins, a relatively low output by U.S. Mint standards, especially compared to the Philadelphia issues of the time. The San Francisco Mint was known for striking coins intended for heavy use in Western commerce, and many of the 1909-S Indian Half Eagles entered circulation and saw significant wear. As a result, examples in lower circulated grades, such as Very Fine, are far more available than uncirculated ones, but still not considered common. Its scarcity becomes more pronounced in higher circulated grades and Mint State condition, pushing demand upward among collectors seeking complete sets or key San Francisco Mint issues.
In Very Fine condition, the 1909-S $5 Indian retains all major details of its original design, though with noticeable flattening on the highest points of both obverse and reverse. On the obverse, wear is most apparent on the cheekbone, feathers of the headdress, and hairline. Despite the wear, the facial features of the Native American and the date remain clear and bold. On the reverse, the eagle’s breast and wing feathers exhibit smoothing, but the general outline and major contours are preserved. Legends such as “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” and “FIVE DOLLARS” remain completely legible, as does the “S” mintmark.
The coin’s color in VF grade is typically a soft, circulated gold hue, with slight darkening or toning in the recesses that can highlight the incuse design. While luster is mostly absent in this grade due to wear, a pleasing, even surface and natural coloration can still yield strong eye appeal. Small abrasions, marks, or light scratches may be present but should not detract significantly from the coin’s overall attractiveness or integrity. Collectors value VF examples for their affordability relative to higher-grade specimens, and for preserving much of the coin’s artistic presence while showing clear signs of historical circulation.
Each 1909-S $5 Indian is composed of 90% gold and 10% copper, with a gross weight of 8.359 grams and a diameter of 21.6 millimeters. The net gold content is 0.24187 troy ounces, giving the coin intrinsic value based on gold’s market price. However, numismatic value typically exceeds melt for scarce issues like the 1909-S, especially in certified or problem-free condition. While the coin may trade close to bullion value in lower grades, VF and above examples with appealing surfaces and no major damage command meaningful premiums from both collectors and investors.
The incuse design of the $5 Indian series was initially met with skepticism by some in the banking and coin-handling sectors, who worried about hygiene and stacking problems. However, those concerns proved unfounded, and the series became one of the most distinctive and artistically admired in American coinage. The unique appearance, combined with the historical resonance of the early 20th century, contributes to enduring interest in the series. The 1909-S, as the second San Francisco Mint issue, reflects the challenges and ambitions of the Mint during this period, particularly in its service to the economic demands of the rapidly developing American West.
The 1909-S has long held appeal among both type collectors and series specialists. As a date with relatively low mintage and a classic mintmark, it represents a more elusive target than its Philadelphia counterparts. In Very Fine condition, it offers a balance between affordability and completeness, ideal for those who appreciate circulated coins with history. Collectors often seek VF coins to complete full circulated sets or as budget-conscious placeholders while they hunt for higher-grade examples. A well-preserved VF coin will still capture the essence of Pratt’s bold and unconventional design while showing honest wear from a century of American commerce.
Certified or raw examples of the 1909-S $5 Indian in VF are increasingly appreciated as numismatic artifacts with both aesthetic and historical value. When encapsulated by reputable grading services such as PCGS or NGC, they offer collectors added confidence regarding authenticity and condition. Coins with attractive toning, even wear, and no significant problems such as cleaning or damage are the most sought after within this grade range. As the coin market continues to place value on classic, pre-1933 U.S. gold, the 1909-S will remain an enduring and worthy piece in any collection.
The $5 Gold Indian 1909-S in Very Fine condition tells a story of artistry, innovation, and history. Its low mintage, unique design, and San Francisco origin distinguish it within the series, while its honest wear reflects a past when gold coins circulated as part of daily economic life. For collectors seeking a tangible connection to early 20th-century America and the evolution of U.S. coinage, this coin offers an exceptional blend of beauty, scarcity, and significance that continues to captivate more than a century after its creation.